Dietary Assessment Methodology for Adolescents: A Review of Reproducibility and Validation Studies

  • Driekie Rankin North-West University
  • Susanna Magrietha Hanekom North-West University
  • Hattie Wright North-West University
  • Una MacIntyre University of Limpopo (Medunsa Campus)
Keywords: Dietary assessment methods, reproducibility, validity, adolescents

Abstract

Aim: The aim of this review is to explore the validity and/or reproducibility of dietary assessment methods used to assess food and nutrient intakes of adolescents. Method: A detailed literature search was undertaken to trace articles reporting on the validity and/or reproducibility of food records, food frequency questionnaires (FFQs) and 24-hour recalls for the dietary assessment of adolescents, especially among South Africans, in the following databases: Medline, Science Direct, Academic Search Premier, Health Source, PubMed and the South African e-publications database (SAE). Original studies published between 1990 and 2009, and relevant original articles published before 1990, were included. Of these, only three were South African-based studies reporting testing for reproducibility and/or validity. Results: Results indicated that adolescents comply better with stimated food records than with weighed food records. However, energy intake was underestimated in dolescents (by 18–42%) when using food record methods. The relative validity of FFQs among adolescents was moderate, with correlation coefficients of > 0.3 for most measured nutrients and food items. Reproducibility was fair to good among female adolescents (0.3–0.83) for most nutrients and foods, but was lower in a South African Tswana-speaking group. The 24-hour recall method showed the least over- and underestimation of all the reviewed methods. When comparing the 24-hour recall method to an observed intake method among adolescents, < 11% underestimation of energy intake was found, while < 4% underestimation was found when the 24-hour recall method was tested against the doubly labelled water method. Conclusion: Based on these outcomes it was concluded that FFQs and 24-hour recalls are valid and reproducible dietary assessment methods that can be used when collecting dietary data from adolescents. Factors to consider when choosing the best suitable method should include the gender and ethnicity of the population as well as the time frame for the collection of dietary data.

Author Biographies

Driekie Rankin, North-West University
PPD RD(SA) PhD (Nutrition) School of Physiology Nutrition and Consumer Science North-West University South Africa
Susanna Magrietha Hanekom, North-West University
RD(SA) PhD (Nutrition) Senior Lecturer School of Physiology Nutrition and Consumer Science North-West University South Africa
Hattie Wright, North-West University
PhD (Dietetics), RD(SA) Senior Lecturer School of Physiology Nutrition and Consumer Science North-West University South Africa
Una MacIntyre, University of Limpopo (Medunsa Campus)
Professor/Director Institute for Human Nutrition University of Limpopo (Medunsa Campus) South Africa
Published
2010-04-24
How to Cite
Rankin, D., Hanekom, S., Wright, H., & MacIntyre, U. (2010). Dietary Assessment Methodology for Adolescents: A Review of Reproducibility and Validation Studies. South African Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 23(2), 65-74. Retrieved from http://sajcn.co.za/index.php/SAJCN/article/view/392
Section
Review Articles